Overhyped Books and What to Do About Them

As everyone with an Internet connection knows, the movie Twilight
I bought the first book in the Twilight series sometime early last year. I did so mostly out of a sense of obligation. I'm a fan of paranormals and YA, so it seemed natural. I'd been hearing a lot about the series, seen the distinctive covers in my local Barnes and Noble, and figured I'd give it shot. It sat on my TBR shelf for months.
By the end of the year, I was sick to death of hearing about the book, the author, and the movie. I found the cast lackluster and not nearly enough incentive to go see a movie I already didn't want to hear anymore about. I finally gave the book to my little sister. She liked it, but thought the Morganville Vampires series by Rachel Caine featured a far superior vampire story.
I hate hype. If I think something is getting massively overplayed in the mediasphere, I tend to avoid it. Rarely has it been worth my time and in the end, I just feel dissatisfied and let down. Bestselling is one thing, but to have it be talked about everywhere I turn just makes me annoyed instead of intrigued.
I've never read the Harry Potter books. That's right, not one. I've accidentally caught snatches of the movies and hope never to have to watch a full one. Until Oprah started doing classics for her Book Club picks, I avoided nearly every one she recommended. Yes, I've read things that were overplayed, some before the hype, some after. And in the end, I'd rather go find something else. Surely there are some great books out there that could use some love and attention?
So, what do I think should be done about books that get too much attention? It's fine to read them - I don't judge anyone for reading and enjoying them. But I do suggest that if you usually only buy books that hit the bestseller lists, to give some of those mid-list authors a try. There are many authors that never quite make that coveted New York Times list, but are certainly worthy of attention. Stroll the aisles of the book store, and pick up a book from someone you've never heard of. Give it a try. You never know, maybe they'll become the next Nora Roberts or Johanna Lindsey.
Nicole







13 Comments:
I don't think that anyone should avoid a book on the off chance that they will be dissatisfied and let down. Bestselling books are are usually bestsellers for a reason. A lot of hype just means their PR person is doing his/her job very well. I've never read the HP books, not because of the hype, but because I just wasn't interested in that story line. I didn't read Twilight until the after the last book came out. I gave in because of "the hype". I'm so glad I did!!!
I'll second that statement. This is the first time I've read a blog post from RT. I hope they are all not so narrow-minded in thinking.
Yes, you shouldn't avoid a book not on the top of the NYT Bestseller list, but you also shouldn't avoid a book that is.
I have heard enough of Twilight
I think Twilight has had enough publicity
I agree with Amye and Fang Story, I bought the entire series after avoiding it, just to see why everyone like it so much, and I love the books. I've also gotten my 13 niece to read like a maniac and she's discover more series books, Morganville Vamps, and some Meg Cabot books because of it and she's excited that her aunt reads them with her. I saw the movie the day it released in theaters and I plan to do the same with new moon.
What I try to do with new books, is put them on an Amazon Wishlist before purchasing them. I am saving so much money, instead of getting a book on release day.
If it's not your cuppa, it's okay, but they sell for a reason.
I am not saying that I haven't read and enjoyed books that were bestsellers - I read Kim Harrison, Jim Butcher, Margaret Atwood and others, and they are all bestsellers. I have also loved MEMOIRS OF A GEISHA and THE TIME TRAVELER'S WIFE, both of which were huge sellers.
What I am saying is that I get sick of hearing about some things to the point where I just can't stand the idea of reading/seeing them. I don't avoid bestsellers, I avoid hype as much as I can.
I may be missing out on something, but for now, I am content to concentrate my reading on authors who can use all the support they can get.
Hype doesn't bother me. I don't make viewing/buying decisions based on it, and I don't focus on it to the point where it becomes an annoyance. It can be fun to be caught up in the excitement of a new book release or the filmed version of a favorite book, and hype also has a way of bringing people with common interests together.
I have to agree with the Nicole, when something is over-hyped, I tend to run (not walk) the other way. I've read all the Harry Potter books, but it wasn't over-hyped when I got into them.
Part of the reason for my aversion to any product (book or otherwise) that is so "loved" is that my tastes almost always go against the "norm". For me, when I see a phenomenon like Twilight, what it really means is that a lot of kids mistake popular for good. While things can be both, it doesn't happen that often.
Plus, despite it's apparent over-hyped status, I have read many bloggers and commenters who have serious issues with the books both in the story-telling and content-wise. It is almost impossible to find good and objective reviews of over-hyped books because they are drowned out by the hype and glitz. I'll take substance over glam anyday.
I have read and watched the Harry Potter series and participated in the midnight parties. I've seen the Twilight movie but haven't quite made it to the book. I have knowingly and intentionally read only two NY Times bestsellers (Memoirs of a Geisha and DaVinci Code) but usually avoid those shelves because the audience they are geared for do not usually share the same tastes as myself.
I don't like hype and usually the supersaturation of cheers and jeers is enough to keep me from "joining the crowd" unless I was there first or enough of my like-minded friends wear me down and loan me their book/dvd/whatever. It's hard to get an honest opinion when all you hear is someone blowing smoke...
Read what you like if its popular or fringe and share your opinions freely.
Kuddos to Nicole for sticking her neck out there and sharing her objective reviews for us to nitpick. It's a shame Fang Stories didn't research your previous blog posts to know the open-minded RT reviewer I've been reading for almost two years.
hey....i would really recommend you the harry potter books...u shd try it. My own sis would not read it, rather she waited for the movies to come out. however this year when she got bored she gave it a try...she likes the books better than the movie and movie doesnt even come close to book....the movie just rips apart the book.
compared to HP books..i dont like twilight series...dont knw why....
For overhyped books I've noticed I either tend to not enjoy them, or like but not love them. I enjoyed the Harry Potter books but they are nowhere near my top favorites. I found the Twilight movie so-so and couldn't get into the book. I'm not sure if nothing can live up to so much hype in my mind, or if I just have different tastes.
IMO, hype is useful because it gets you to pick up a book and read the back cover. After that, what you do is completely up to you. If you avoid a book just because it's been overhyped, then you may be missing out on some wonderful reading material. I buy a book if the story sounds interesting to me, don't buy it if it doesn't. I don't care how a book first came to my attention, whether through hype or bookstore happenstance.
I adore the Harry Potter books and so do my kids. I read them in spite of the hype. I understand hating the whole overdone hype thing but in the case of HP I think it's justified. The Twilight series was ok but I'm with Stephen King in that I don't think that Meyer is anywhere near as good of a writer as Rowling. I'm a voracious reader and understand how frustrating it is that some authors get overhyped when there are so many excellent ones out there who never do. Personally I would rather read Karen Marie Moning, Alexandra Ivy, Nalini Singh, or Lora Leigh to name just a few but hey, that's just me.
Post a Comment
<< Home